*Shipping zip codes in and near Highland Park, NJ maybe eligible for free local delivery. Enter your shipping zip into Discount Code at Checkout to see if your order is eligible for free delivery.*

Cart: 0

Cart 0

Through the Moongate + -
Over the Moon Toys + -
About Us
Blog
Log in
Create account

Plush Toys

Browse by

Sort by

Bashful Black & Cream Puppy

From $ 14.99

Bashful Toffee Puppy

From $ 14.95

Bashful Unicorn

From $ 14.95

Bashful Honey Bear

From $ 14.95

Squiggles Puppy

$ 14.95

Bashful Baby Bunny

$ 7.95

Perry Polar Bear Small

$ 19.95

Sold Out

Emile Elephant

From $ 29.95

Bashful Beige Bunny

From $ 14.99

Bashful Unicorn Baby - Through the Moongate and Over the Moon Toys

Bashful Unicorn Rattle and Soother

From $ 12.95

Bashful Bunny Beau Blue

From $ 14.95

Squiggle Bunny

$ 14.95

Bashful Owl

From $ 14.95

Duffie Dino Baby

From $ 17.95

Bashful Hippo Baby - Through the Moongate and Over the Moon Toys

Bashful Hippo Rattle and Soother

From $ 12.95

Bashful Bunny Chime

$ 19.95

Riley Rabbit

$ 19.95

Dancing Darcey

$ 14.99